The Natural State

Matthew Dougherty

Director’s statement

I was born into a fundamentalist Christian cult. My mother got my sister and me out while I was still small, and not long after, I began to have recurring nightmares.

One night I woke frightened and ran to my mother’s bed and nudged her awake. She lifted her head and turned to me, only she was not my mother. “Your mother is in the hospital.” I was five years old.

My parents had joined the cult when they were teenagers. What had begun for them as an innocent yearning to share Jesus’ love with the world became a horrific chronicle of abuse at the hands of the cult leader, who for decades abused countless young women, including my mother. She stayed in the psychiatric hospital for several months, and my sister and I went to live with my father, who had also left the cult but remained a practicing fundamentalist, determined to instill a love of God in his children.

As a teenager I started to practice meditation, and then later, with the help of psychedelics, I began to get glimpses of what to me felt like profound, egoless states of consciousness. The experience of myself as a distinct individual dissolved. Yet no matter how boundless the experience, my illusory ego always came bouncing back.

At some point I learned of a number of people who claimed to have had powerful and irreversible spiritual awakenings that left them permanently in the state that I had only tasted. They spoke of the urgency for an evolutionary shift out of the ego that had dominated our species for so long and was leading us to our collective ruin. I read all the books that I could find and watched video after video. Eventually I paid to go see a few of the teachers in person and sat in a crowd while they talked in soothing voices through miked headsets about Oneness. But it was impossible to see past their aloof demeanor, or peer behind their big foundations, the trademarked meditation techniques and expensive spiritual retreats, to see what it really meant for them, as regular people, to live in an awakened state.

In the spring of 2007, in a small town on the coast of Northern Italy, U.G. Krishnamurti passed away. About a year later, a video of U.G. from his deathbed, a man I had never heard of, ended up on my screen.

I felt repulsed. He didn’t have any of the spiritual qualities of the teachers I had been listening to. He seemed angry, spewing almost, boasting about himself with a group of people scattered around him on the floor lapping it all up. I pitied anyone foolish enough to be lost in him.

A few months later I chanced upon another video, this one decades earlier. The combativeness was still there, yelling at people about their stupid questions, but this time I noticed an unusual softness in the way he moved.

After that it was over. I watched every video and read every book I could find. What I fell for was not only the ideas but the physical fact of him. The humor, the beauty, the fearlessness, the cruelty, the spark in the eye. He had no organization, no followers, no copyright on any of his books. He kept an open door wherever he went, anyone could meet him without an appointment, free of charge. He refused donations. He was brutally dismissive of anything to do with spirituality and insisted he had nothing anyone could receive. Yet he claimed an awakening of his own decades earlier, one that left him in what he called the Natural State. An honest guru, I thought. A true one.

Then in the summer of 2008 I found the journal Julie Thayer kept while traveling with U.G., posted online. Julie was a wealthy American woman who met him in the late 80s and quickly became very close to him. Only the journal is not merely the chronicle of a spiritual path. It is the record of a woman handing herself over piece by piece to some sort of black hole. Reading it, I lost my footing. I could not locate the line between an ego being dismantled and a person being taken apart, and it was not clear that Julie had located it either. Her writing led me to her archive, hundreds of hours of home video shot from inside U.G.’s intimate circle. She had not filmed from a safe distance. She put herself in the fire and kept the camera running. Almost none of it had ever been seen.

How do you tell the difference between someone taking your ego apart and someone using you?

I borrowed a few thousand dollars and a camera from a friend and set out. Traveling country to country to meet people who had known U.G., I picked up scattered recordings, photographs and old films, much of it never seen or heard before. And the more people I met, the more the contradictions multiplied. Everyone held a different piece of him. Everyone had their own U.G. Was it all projection, or was there something there? Of course I wanted to believe.

But the blank stare one witness describes as a man with nobody home is the same stare a clinician would call dissociation and a skeptic would call a practiced effect. The testimony could not settle it. The footage could not settle it. I spent sixteen years assembling what is probably the most complete archive of this man that exists, and it does not settle it. At some point I stopped treating that as the obstacle in front of the film and started treating it as the film itself.

I did not want to make either of the two films this subject usually produces, the exposé or the hagiography. I wanted a spiritual film for a secular audience, one that does not ask anyone to believe anything but also challenges the quick-to-dismiss cynicism of our times.

This is a film assembled almost entirely from another person’s footage, shot by a woman who was inside what she was recording. What she captured is not evidence in the ordinary sense. It is a record of one person’s belief, and the film asks an audience to sit inside that belief without being told what to do with it.

U.G. called the Natural State a state of not knowing. That is the glimpse this film has aimed at.

Matthew Dougherty

Where to see the film

Enter your email to be notified first when The Natural State screens in your city or becomes available to stream at home.

Only news about upcoming screenings.